The political temperature between Japan and China is rising again over the Senkaku/Diaoyu islands. Once more oil appears to be a principal issue – as it was in the period leading up to the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor. The road to Pearl Harbor and from there to the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki that have shaped so much of the world ever needs to be clearly illuminated, now more than at any time since the end of World War II. The question of whether Japan should consider developing its own nuclear weapons is moving into the political discourse and even some acceptability. The former Governor of Tokyo who resigned to run for national office as head of the newly formed right wing Japan Restoration Party won 61 of the 480 seats in the lower house of Japan’s Parliament (the Diet). Mr. Ishihara has “suggested there is a need for Japan to arm itself with nuclear weapons, expand the military and revise the pacifist constitution,” according to new reports. See more: http://www.theprovince.com/news/Nationalists+take+power+Japan+fire+warning+shot+China/7707292/story.html#ixzz2FLjApjLp
On August 4, 2012 I gave a talk in Santa Fe, New Mexico on the history of US-Japanese relations that led up to rising tensions and the bombing of Pearl Harbor and of events from that time till the use of the atom bombs on Japan. More than 67 years after those bombings, few know that Japanese forces were first targeted on May 5, 1943 as the preferred target for those atom bombs, long before the bombs were built and well before anyone knew when the war would be over. In fact, Germany was explicitly de-targeted on that same date by the Military Policy Committee. Watch a video of the talk here.
This speech has a different perspective in many ways than are common in US discourse of the bombings. One side only discusses the evidence that the bombings were unjustified; the other points to Japanese militarism and the intensity of the violence in the Pacific Theater of World War II to justify the use of the bombs. I sought to affirm the truths in both arguments but added much that has been missing. So I would particularly welcome your comments on this speech and blog post. If you think you’ve learned something new, we encourage you to ask radio stations and television stations to use this material. It was broadcast on KEXP in Seattle shortly after the anniversary of Pearl Harbor earlier this month.
[…] and listeners are invited to post comments on Makhijani’s Blog on the IEER.org web site at http://ieer.org/disarmament/from-pearl-harbor-to-hiroshima/ Arjun Makhijani spoke on August 4, 2012 at the Nuke Free Now Conference in Santa Fe, New […]
Pingback by From Pearl Harbor to Hiroshima _ on Anti-War Progressive Teach-in | NO LIES RADIO — February, 2013 @ 10:32 am
I am listening to the series on KALW-FM TUC Radio programming Sunday mornings & appreciate your history greatly. I was lucky to have a teacher, Mr,]. Murchi, in high school who had been locked up with his Japanese family as a small boy. He taught us some of your truth about Pearl Harbor [That the attacks were related to the US pushing Japan into action and that Mac Arthur knew] This small truth was denied as I went into college and after, so I am grateful to you and Mr. Murchi for informing me.
The reason I write other than gratitude for your work on this topic is the new NOAA projection of a long term and deep drought in the next few years to histthe SW U.S. and California. I am concerned about the issues around fracking in the San Joachin Valley and its poisoning of water resources if fracking continues to be practiced and the projection of this drought occurs. I have found NOAA to be very accurate in their measurements and predictions.
While this issue may seem off-topic,I appreciate your integrity and deeper perspective and feel you can shed light on this issue if, you are so inclined.Thank you!
Comment by KO — February, 2013 @ 10:41 am
I am listening to the series on KALW-FM TUC Radio programming Sunday mornings & appreciate your history greatly. I was lucky to have a teacher, Mr. Murchi, in high school who had been locked up with his Japanese family as a small boy. He taught us some of your truth about Pearl Harbor [That the attacks were related to the US pushing Japan into action and that Mac Arthur knew] This small truth was denied as I went into college and after, so I am grateful to you and Mr. Murchi for informing me.
The reason I write other than gratitude for your work on this topic, is the new NOAA projection of a long term and deep drought in the next few years in the SW U.S. and California. I am concerned about the issues around fracking in the San Joachin Valley and its poisoning of water resources if fracking continues to be practiced and the projection of this drought occurs. I have found NOAA to be very accurate in their measurements and predictions.
While this issue may seem off-topic,I appreciate your integrity and deeper perspective and feel you can shed light on this issue if, you are so inclined.Thank you!
Comment by KO — February, 2013 @ 10:43 am
Thank you for posting this talk, having visited Hiroshima with an Aussie woman who worked on the bomb & apologized to the major of Hiroshima personally, now seeing what it did.
Then, with a hunch that no Admiral would ever put all the main guns of a fleet in a tiny space when it was known the Japanese were not far away.
What was researched supports a lot of my thoughts just growing up with post-war & having a Japanese-American who taught me their side, so, this is a global view of how corrupt the whole thing was, the final ethic was to make the project successful money-wise, it had nothing to do with military issues.
This is an indictment of the decision to drop the bombs, it was to “look good”.
How sick, “… the ends justify the means”.
Comment by Tom Mallard — March, 2013 @ 7:57 pm
It’s 2:08 a.m. monday morning & I just heard your talk on TUC Radio.Org,you said Richard Feynman was on the Manhattan Project, that I didn’t know that. Was he old enough to be on that project? There was only 3 places that were used for the project and CalTec was not 1 of them. I know Jon Gofman was on the team. He was the 1 that made Plutonium 239 for the second bomb! It was 2.5 grams, right off hand I forget exactly how much he made. There is a talk about it on TUC Radio.Org. Do you know what Einstien said after he saw his first atomic detonation? He said, “My God, What Have I Done”? Oppenhiemer took Einstien’s equation, E=mc squared, and made it work on the atomic level. The closest the Nazi’s ever came to making an atomic device was heavy water, acording too Heisenberg, who was thier chief physicist.
Comment by Adam Kovelesky — April, 2013 @ 2:13 am
[…] talk and listeners are invited to post comments on Makhijani’s Blog on the IEER.org web site at <http://ieer.org/disarmament/from-pearl-harbor-to-hiroshima/> Arjun Makhijani spoke on August 4, 2012 at the Nuke Free Now Conference in Santa Fe, New Mexico. […]
Pingback by TUC Radio / Arjun Makhijani – From Pearl Harbor to Hiroshima (Part TWO of TWO) | jkmhoffman — July, 2014 @ 2:09 pm
I wonder what it was never mentioned that the committee could have decided to drop the atomic bomb on a deserted island to show the power of the bomb. I remember a documentary that said this option was discussed and dismissed. Did this discussion really happen?
Comment by George Forman — August, 2014 @ 7:55 am